What Is Cultural Appropriation?

Cultural appropriation happens when people from a dominant group take or use elements of a minority culture like clothing, language, music, or traditions without understanding, respect, or permission. This can lead to stereotypes, disrespect, or even harm to the original culture.

1. Exchange

This is a fair and mutual sharing between two cultures that have equal power. Both sides benefit and agree to the exchange.

  • Example: Two communities collaborate on a music project, blending their styles with mutual respect and credit.

2. Dominance

This happens when a powerful culture adopts parts of a weaker culture, especially one it has historically controlled or colonized.

  • Example: A colonizing country adopts Indigenous clothing or rituals while continuing to suppress the people who created them.

3. Exploitation

This is when a dominant group takes cultural elements from a marginalized group without permission, payment, or acknowledgment.

  • Example: A fashion brand profits from tribal designs without crediting or compensating the community it copied from.

4. Transculturation

This is a complex blending of cultures where elements are mixed so deeply that it’s hard to tell where they originally came from.

  • Example: Modern street food that combines Asian, Latin, and Western flavors in ways that reflect many influences at once.

Cordillera IPs Defend the Bahag from Misuse

(Read the full story from: Philstar.com)

The bahag is a traditional loincloth worn by Indigenous men in the Cordillera region. It’s not just clothing, it holds deep cultural meaning, symbolizing identity, heritage, and respect for tradition.

In 2022, controversy erupted when contestants in an international male pageant wore the bahag during a swimsuit competition. Many Cordillera Indigenous Peoples (IPs) and cultural advocates felt that the way it was worn, tucked and styled like modern swimwear, was disrespectful and stripped of its cultural context. Some online posts even sexualized the attire, which added to the offense.

The National Commission on Indigenous Peoples (NCIP) in the Cordillera responded by reminding the public that traditional garments like the bahag should be treated with dignity. They emphasized that only the community has the right to decide how their cultural symbols are used or adapted. The NCIP also supported possible actions by the community to protect their heritage from misuse.

This incident sparked broader conversations about cultural appropriation, especially when Indigenous symbols are used for entertainment or profit without proper understanding or consent.

Key challenges Indigenous Peoples in the Philippines

Upland Displacement and Land Classification

As lowland areas were taken over for development and resource extraction, many Indigenous communities moved into the highlands. However, under Philippine law, land with a slope over 18 degrees is classified as “public forest land,” meaning it cannot be owned or sold. This land falls under the control of the Forest Management Bureau (FMB) of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR). Even though millions of people, including Indigenous groups, live in these areas, they are still often labeled as “informal settlers”, which undermines their ancestral claims.

Government Programs and Shifting Approaches

In the 1970s, the government began to recognize that punishing Indigenous communities wasn’t working. Instead, it launched programs like the Integrated Social Forestry Program (ISFP) to:

  • Let Indigenous people stay on their land
  • Encourage sustainable farming and conservation
  • Promote cooperation instead of conflict

This marked a shift toward supportive engagement rather than forced removal.

Conflict Zones and Militarization

Many Indigenous communities live in areas affected by armed conflict, especially in Mindanao. They’ve been caught in the crossfire between: State forces and Rebel groups like the New People’s Army (NPA) and the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF)

These conflicts have led to displacement, violence, and fear, making it even harder for Indigenous Peoples to protect their land and way of life.

Legal Protections vs. Reality

The Philippines has progressive laws like the Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Act (IPRA), which recognizes ancestral domains. However, these laws are not always enforced

  • Indigenous rights are often ignored in favor of business or military interests
  • Real progress has come mostly from grassroots organizing, not from top-down reforms

Despite legal recognition and some government programs, Indigenous Peoples in the Philippines still face major challenges:

  • Their lands are often classified in ways that deny them ownership
  • They are vulnerable to displacement, conflict, and environmental destruction
  • True progress has come from their own efforts, not just from government action
Questions:
  1. In the absence of strong legal enforcement, how have Indigenous communities used grassroots advocacy to reclaim space and assert their rights? Evaluate the strengths and limitations of bottom-up resistance in the face of institutional neglect.
  2. How have armed conflicts in Mindanao exacerbated the displacement and disenfranchisement of Indigenous Peoples? Discuss the human rights impact of militarization on community organizing, education, and land defense.
Post your response in the comment section, then choose another response to reply with your opinion

Real-World Examples

Here are some of the most pressing issues, along with real-world examples:

1. Land Disputes and Ancestral Domain Insecurity

Many IP communities struggle to secure legal recognition of their ancestral lands, despite the Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Act (IPRA) of 1997.

Examples:

The Higaonon tribe in Northern Mindanao has faced displacement due to mining and palm oil agribusiness operations, despite their ancestral claims.

The Ayta Mag-indi community in Porac, Pampanga, continues to assert their land rights amid development pressures.

2. Resource Exploitation and Environmental Degradation

Large-scale mining, logging, and dam projects often encroach on indigenous territories without proper consultation or consent.

Example: In the Cordillera region, indigenous opposition to the Chico River Dam project in the 1970s became a landmark resistance movement. Similar struggles continue today against mining in the area.

3. Poverty and Marginalization

IPs are among the most impoverished groups in the country, with limited access to education, healthcare, and infrastructure.

Example: Many Lumad communities in Mindanao live in remote areas with little access to schools or clinics, making basic services a daily challenge.

4. Cultural Erosion and Misrepresentation

Modernization, migration, and media stereotypes contribute to the loss of indigenous languages, traditions, and identity.

Example: Indigenous practices are often misrepresented in textbooks and media, reinforcing harmful stereotypes rather than celebrating cultural diversity.

5. Political Exclusion and Human Rights Violations

IPs are frequently excluded from decision-making processes and are vulnerable to harassment, militarization, and even violence.

Example: Lumad schools have been red-tagged and shut down, with teachers and students accused of insurgency links, despite their focus on culturally relevant education.

Read the full story

References

  1. Higaonon Tribe Land Disputes (Misamis Oriental, Mindanao)

Rappler. (2023). Misamis Oriental land rush threatens Higaonon ancestral domain. Read the article

Oxford Research Group. (2017). Weavers of Peace: The Higaonon Tribe in the Philippines. View source

  1. Ayta Mag-indi Ancestral Domain Recognition (Porac, Pampanga)

Philippine News Agency. (2022). Pampanga IPs get 18.6K-hectare ancestral land after 13 years. View article

Porac LGU. (2022). Victory for Porac Indigenous Peoples!. Official statement

  1. Chico River Dam Resistance (Cordillera Region)

Wikipedia. Chico River Dam Project. Background and history

Cambridge University Press. (2023). Peace pacts and contentious politics: The Chico River Dam struggle in the Philippines, 1974–82. Academic article

  1. Lumad Communities and Access to Education and Healthcare (Mindanao)

Davao Today. (2019). Mindanao Lumad struggle for empowerment through education. Full report

CLANS. (2018). Center for Lumad Advocacy, Networking and Services. Program overview

  1. Red-tagging and Human Rights Violations Against Lumad Schools

The Organization for World Peace. (2021). Fighting For An Education: Lumad Schools Under Attack. Read more

Rappler. (2021). Correcting the injustices against the Lumad schools. Opinion piece

 Question:

To what extent do state and corporate interests in natural resource development override indigenous rights to land and consultation? Analyze using historical and contemporary examples, such as the Chico River Dam project and mining in the Cordillera region.

Post your response in the comment section, then choose another response to reply with your opinion

Download this Activity